Inactive subscribers aren’t lost — they just need a reason to care again. Targeted, value-driven campaigns can reignite interest and keep your list healthy, improving deliverability and engagement.
Over time, even the most engaged email lists accumulate subscribers who stop opening messages. Instead of ignoring them, you can use re-engagement campaigns to bring them back. The goal isn’t to beg for attention but to remind subscribers why they joined in the first place.
Platforms like Systeme.io or Kit make it simple to segment inactive subscribers and send automated sequences tailored to re-sparking engagement.
Step 1: Identify inactivity
Start by defining what “inactive” means for your audience. Common benchmarks:
-
No opens or clicks in 30–60 days
-
No interaction with a key lead magnet or content
-
Not visiting your site in a month or more
Once identified, isolate this group in your email platform for targeted messaging.
Step 2: Offer value, not pressure
Re-engagement emails should remind subscribers why they signed up. Consider these approaches:
-
Share your best tips or resources in a digestible format
-
Offer exclusive insights or updates
-
Pose a question or quick poll to encourage interaction
The idea is to rebuild trust and relevance before asking them to take action.
Step 3: Use a short, clear sequence
A typical re-engagement series could be:
-
Reminder email – Highlight what they get by staying subscribed.
-
Value email – Offer a free resource, tip, or insight.
-
Decision email – Give them a simple choice: stay subscribed or opt out.
Automation tools like Drip or ActiveCampaign let you trigger these emails automatically once a subscriber hits your inactivity criteria.
Step 4: Experiment with timing and subject lines
Open rates matter most for re-engagement. Try different subject lines that spark curiosity or emphasize benefit, such as:
-
“Still interested in improving your email game?”
-
“Your free guide is waiting…”
-
“Let’s catch up — we’ve missed you”
Timing can vary based on your audience — some respond better mid-week, others on weekends. Test to find the sweet spot.
Step 5: Decide on pruning
Not every inactive subscriber will return. After your sequence, consider removing persistent non-engagers from your active list. Maintaining a healthy list improves deliverability, reduces costs, and ensures your engaged subscribers continue to receive valuable content.
Key takeaways
-
Segment inactive subscribers — don’t treat them like the rest of the list.
-
Deliver concise, relevant value before asking for action.
-
Use automation to keep the process efficient.
-
Test subject lines, content, and timing to find what works best.
-
Keep your list clean — inactive subscribers cost more than they contribute.
Re-engagement campaigns are about respect and relevance, not pressure. When done thoughtfully, they can rejuvenate a segment of your list that would otherwise go dormant — improving engagement and future sales.
